After many years on the internet, I have eventually learned never to say "Nobody wants X"
Somebody always wants X, and will make sure everyone knows.
And on this case, yes, many people (most people here) want socialism very much.
A place for for news, discussion, memes, and links criticizing capitalism and advancing viewpoints that challenge liberal capitalist ideology. That means any support for any liberal capitalist political party (like the Democrats) is strictly prohibited.
A zero-tolerance policy for bigotry of any kind. Failure to respect this will result in a ban.
RULES:
1 Understand the left starts at anti-capitalism.
2 No Trolling
3 No capitalist apologia, anti-socialism, anti-communism, or liberalism, liberalism is in direct conflict with the left. Support for capitalism or for the parties or ideologies that uphold it are not welcome or tolerated.
4 No imperialism, conservatism, reactionism or Zionism, lessor evil rhetoric. Dismissing 3rd party votes or 'wasted votes on 3rd party' is lessor evil rhetoric.
5 No bigotry, no racism, sexism, antisemitism, homophobia, transphobia, ableism, or any type of prejudice.
6 Be civil in comments and no accusations of being a bot, 'paid by Putin,' Tankie, etc. This includes instance shaming.
Introduction to Socialism (external links)
Marxism-Leninism Study Guide: Basic Course
Marxism-Leninism Study Guide: Advanced Course
After many years on the internet, I have eventually learned never to say "Nobody wants X"
Somebody always wants X, and will make sure everyone knows.
And on this case, yes, many people (most people here) want socialism very much.
What they want is the bastardized version of socialism that's been spoon fed to the by liberals. The version where taxation is socialism, public services are socialism, the wealthy are ok as long as they are taxed, the Nordic model. That's the version they want, to work within the confines of capitalism to keep an oppressive welfare safte5
In my experience most people actually want the real deal. They just don't know it because they are scared of the word. Most people do not care for rich people. Most people want more workplace democracy. Most people do not want ecosystems destroyed or innocent people exploited or killed. Most people also don't like the threat of homelessness or poverty. They don't like manipulative advertisement or enshittification. It is also not that they don't care about imperialism. They either are trained to reject that reality (cognitive dissonance is incredibly powerful) or are taught that people from the global south deserve it. Mostly it is a mixture of both. The reality of systemic exploitation is rejected and muslims etc. are culturally/racially inferior. The latter one is usually more an argument on the far right though. But even then, i've known people that were outright racist and sexist but were the (genuinely) nicest people when interacting with individuals (after getting to know them). They believe what they believe because they are taught to believe that.
In my experience when talking to liberals or the normal "mainstream leftists" without class consciousness, these people will usually agree with all details but once the scary s-word is dropped, they'll either say "oh but socialism doesn't work" or "oh but socialism always leads to authoritarian dictatorships".
That is why i like the talks by jason hickel. He will talk about all detrimental effects of capitalism and the lack of democracy at work and back all of it up with statistics and studies and everyone is usually on board. And then at the end he "reveals" that that is actually socialism. At that point dismantling all the usual anti-communist talking points is much easier, because it is not "capitalism is almost perfect and socialism needs to be that few percent better", it is more "capitalism is pretty much destroying the world and socialism is the only way to prevent that". He does not even need to go into tankie territory in the end but occasionally he does.
talks by jason hickel
Any you would suggest in particular?
We already built the social democracy system. FDR built it in the New Deal. The reply is dead on, we have empirically proven that it is temporary because Nixon, Reagan and everyone since has torn it down, beholden to the financial interests of the oligarchs. As long as money has the means, the incentive, and free reign to erode the system, of course it will.
That's a bit of a long stretch as the New Deal was never about shifting to a social democrat system nor was it trying to. FDR built it as an economic recovery program to the Great Depression in a period of intense political instability that's all it was.
He DID want to implement a system as outlined in his Second Bill of Rights but he died before he managed to make a program for it.
Fun fact: It is impossible to solve unemployment under Capitalism. The moment demand for labour exceeds supply, wages start increasing until profits are gone. There has to be an unemployed, desperate class for wages to stay under control and businesses profitable.
Some related theory if anyone's interested, written in the 1920s:
'How does capitalism keep the unemployed on hand?’ you ask.
Simply by compelling you to work long hours and as hard as possible, so as to produce the greatest amount. All the modern schemes of ‘efficiency’, the Taylor and other systems of ‘economy’ and ‘rationalization’ serve only to squeeze greater profits out of the worker. It is economy in the interest of the employer only. But as concerns you, the worker, this ‘economy’ spells the greatest expenditure of your effort and energy, a fatal waste of your vitality.
It pays the employer to use up and exploit your strength and ability at the highest tension. True, it ruins your health and breaks down your nervous system, makes you a prey to illness and disease (there are even special proletarian diseases), cripples you and brings you to an early grave — but what does your boss care? Are there not thousands of unemployed waiting for your job and ready to take it the moment you are disabled or dead?
That is why it is to the profit of the capitalist to keep an army of unemployed ready at hand. It is part and parcel of the wage system, a necessary and inevitable characteristic of it.
It is in the interest of the people that there should be no unemployed, that all should have an opportunity to work and earn their living; that all should help, each according to his ability and strength, to increase the wealth of the country, so that each should be able to have a greater share of it.
But capitalism is not interested in the welfare of the people. Capitalism, as I have shown before, is interested only in profits. By employing less people and working them long hours larger profits can be made than by giving work to more people at shorter hours. That is why it is to the interest of your employer, for instance, to have 100 people work 10 hours daily rather than to employ 200 at 5 hours. He would need more room for 200 than for 100 persons — a larger factory, more tools and machinery, and so on. That is, he would require a greater investment of capital. The employment of a larger force at less hours would bring less profits, and that is why your boss will not run his factory or shop on such a plan. Which means that a system of profit-making is not compatible with considerations of humanity and the well-being of the workers. On the contrary, the harder and more ‘efficiently’ you work and the longer hours you stay at it, the better for your employer and the greater his profits.
You can therefore see that capitalism is not interested in employing all those who want and are able to work. On the contrary: a minimum of ‘hands’ and a maximum of effort is the principle and the profit of the capitalist system. This is the whole secret of all ‘rationalization’ schemes. And that is why you will find thousands of people in every capitalist country willing and anxious to work, yet unable to get employment. This army of unemployed is a constant threat to your standard of living. They are ready to take your place at lower pay, because necessity compels them to it. That is, of course, very advantageous to the boss: it is a whip in his hands constantly held over you, so you will slave hard for him and ‘behave’ yourself.
You can see for yourself how dangerous and degrading such a situation is for the worker, not to speak of the other evils of the system.
‘Then why not do away with unemployment?’ you demand.
Yes, it would be fine to do away with it. But it could be accomplished only by doing away with the capitalist system and its wage slavery. As long as you have capitalism — or any other system of labor exploitation and profit-making — you will have unemployment. Capitalism can’t exist without it: it is inherent in the wage system. It is the fundamental condition of successful capitalist production.
‘Why?’
Because the capitalist industrial system does not produce for the needs of the people; it produces for profit. Manufacturers do not produce commodities because the people want them and as much of them as is required. They produce what they expect to sell, and sell at a profit.
If we had a sensible system, we would produce the things which the people want and the quantity they need. Suppose the inhabitants of a certain locality needed 1,000 pairs of shoes; and suppose we’d have 50 shoemakers for the job. Then in 20 hours work those shoemakers would produce the shoes our community needs.
But the shoemaker of to-day does not know and does not care how many pairs of shoes are needed. Thousands of people may need new shoes in your city, but they cannot afford to buy them. So what good is it to the manufacturer to know who needs shoes? What he wants to know is who can buy the shoes he makes: how many pairs he can sell at a profit.
What happens? Well, he will manufacture about as many pairs of shoes as he thinks he will be able to sell. He will try his best to produce them as cheaply and sell them as dearly as he can, so as to make a good profit. He will therefore employ as few workers as possible to manufacture the quantity of shoes he wants, and he will have them work as ‘efficiently’ and hard as he can compel them to.
You see that production for profit means longer hours and fewer persons employed than would be the case if production were for use.
Capitalism is the system of production for profit, and that is why capitalism always must have unemployed.
But look further into this system of production for profit and you will see how its basic evil works a hundred other evils.
Let us follow the shoe manufacturer of your city...
From Now and After by Alexander Berkman. Chapter 5: Unemployment.
Available to read or download in various formats, for free, here: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/alexander-berkman-what-is-communist-anarchism
Bingo.
There is a path towards syndicalism. A progressive wealth cap. Which forces the assets transferred from private equities to co-op-like structures, forming employee/consumer-owned corporations. The beauty is that the wealth is still isolated from the state to avoid authoritarianism. Then, remove the remaining centralized power structure that reduces the risk of any power corruption.
One can only dream
As a white man, I speak for everyone.
whoah there pardner!
/s in case you need that
I'm pro social democracy. Provided all companies are worker owned coops or run by the state with a powerful workers union.
Organizing powerful labor groups, then telling their members "this far and no further" when it comes to economic planning?
Democratic socialist here. Yes, socialism is better than capitalism with safety nets. We're working on it.
I'd be happy with a strong social democracy, with the larger exploitive companies (ie lumbermills, oil companies, mines) owned by the public.
I would like socialism, please and thank you.
We can still tax the billionaires at 90% and they're still wealthy beyond most people's dreams. If they take that money and use it for socialized medicine not putting it in their own pockets for death and destruction in places that we should have no business being in I think America might have a chance. And we just really need states to pull their heads out of their asses and vote in term limits. These assholes that are in government for 20 to 50 years is an insult to whatever Republic we have left.
Germany and UK great example of that reply irl
I definitely want socialism. When a worker produce value under socialism, the added value goes back to him instead of a vault of a ghoul.