Late Stage Capitalism
A place for for news, discussion, memes, and links criticizing capitalism and advancing viewpoints that challenge liberal capitalist ideology. That means any support for any liberal capitalist political party (like the Democrats) is strictly prohibited.
A zero-tolerance policy for bigotry of any kind. Failure to respect this will result in a ban.
RULES:
1 Understand the left starts at anti-capitalism.
2 No Trolling
3 No capitalist apologia, anti-socialism, anti-communism, or liberalism, liberalism is in direct conflict with the left. Support for capitalism or for the parties or ideologies that uphold it are not welcome or tolerated.
4 No imperialism, conservatism, reactionism or Zionism, lessor evil rhetoric. Dismissing 3rd party votes or 'wasted votes on 3rd party' is lessor evil rhetoric.
5 No bigotry, no racism, sexism, antisemitism, homophobia, transphobia, ableism, or any type of prejudice.
6 Be civil in comments and no accusations of being a bot, 'paid by Putin,' Tankie, etc. This includes instance shaming.
Introduction to Socialism (external links)
Marxism-Leninism Study Guide: Basic Course
Marxism-Leninism Study Guide: Advanced Course
view the rest of the comments
Were some civil liberties preserved? Absolutely! Education, healthcare, and low rents were very real impacts of that socialist system. The USSR did a great job in that regard.
But other civil liberties, like freedom of speech and freedom from surveillance, were heavily restricted, especially toward the end of the USSR.
We could hold another revolution, but I could pose the same question: why will it be different from all the revolutions that collapsed into authoritarianism? Neither reform nor revolution has worked sustainably to build a system that survives long-term and respects rights while also protecting its people from ignorance, starvation, and lack of healthcare.
I think it's worth it to keep trying instead of giving up. Another revolution would cost more lives and fall into authoritarian hands the same way. Who knows: maybe it wouldn't. But I prefer a democratic solution. And I think a system founded on democracy has a better chance of maintaining democracy. In part, this is because people are more likely to revolt against a system that was imposed upon them than a system they participated in from the beginning.
We don't have to see eye to eye, but I hope you at least agree that my stance isn't ludicrous. I also want to clarify that I don't think the USSR was entirely a failed government. It did a lot of things well, but I think, especially as time progressed, it was limiting of individual freedoms that it should have respected and protected.
In the event that you take power, is your plan to leave capitalists with full freedom of speech, assembly, and with no surveillance? All states are class dictatorships. This means democracy for the ruling class, with the state oppressing that which works against the interests of the ruling class. This is why we cannot reform capitalism into socialism, but even magically assuming we get through that first hurdle and establish socialism electorally, what do you do about the capitalists?
To answer your question on "why would revolution be different," my answer is that it would largely be the same, and that's a great thing. Using the US as an example, if socialist revolution succeeded, we would already be far past much of what existing socialist states have had to struggle through, like advancing agriculture and industrialization. We would also have many of the same progressive aspects socialist states built with far fewer resources.
Socialist states are already democratic. The systems they put in place to fight against capital and protect the gains of socialism, such as people's councils and democratic centralism, look utterly alien to us in the capitalist west, where we confuse the ritual of electing pre-selected heads of state every few years with democracy. I encourage you to not look at the hundreds of millions of workers that spent their lives building up socialism and fighting to protect it as foolish and ignorant, but instead to learn from them and carry their work forward.
Until you do so, I'm sorry, but I cannot see your stance as anything other than naive and unprincipled. I implore you to take a scientific approach, and be able to answer why reformism will work this time, otherwise everyone will eventually recognize the necessity of revolution as you fail to answer that important question.
All people should have their individual rights and freedoms respected, including these people. There are other methods of preventing a ruling class, best used in conjunction:
As for surveillance, warrants should be required, and those being surveilled should always be made aware of their surveilled status.
Insofar as free speech is concerned, all people should be given total free speech with the exceptions of slander and calls to violence against minorities or any particular individual.
In some ways, yes. In others, less so. It really depends on the state and the window of time being analyzed. Some states have been very authoritarian, while also being socialist, at least during part of their lifespan.
I don't view them as foolish or ignorant. They were intelligent people who had the same goal as I do. I disagree with the methodology of some of them, but we are all working toward social equity.
Part of my objection to revolt is the means. The ends, in my view, do not justify the means Nevertheless, your position is intelligent, and I respect it despite my disagreement. I won't bash you over the head with my stance, since I think it's been discussed at length.
I think we must all practice intellectual humility; we are likely both misguided in some way or another.
Still, I think disagreement is not always naïveté. I have, as you, thought this through; we came to different conclusions, and that's fine. Discourse exists to confer ideas and reasoning, after all. Whether we concur on methodology, our end goal is the same or similar, and that is more important than the method.
The measures you suggest do not limit the capitalist class, and allowing them to form coherent political blocs against the working class and overturn socialism is frankly a moralist stance that endangers the working class. The socialists that have succeeded in building socialism have built the strong protections they have out of necessity, not a simple desire to command. Throughout this comment, I'm still not understanding why you think this time will be different from every other time a well-meaning reformist has taken power and immediately been ousted by open gangsterism.
I don't call you naive and unprincipled to be mean, I mean them quite literally, I don't see any practical substance that tackles the problem of capitalist dictatorship nor addresses the history of the capitalist class violently resisting any and all progressive movements, reformist or revolutionary, every single time. I think you're coasting off of hope, not science.
I think, in conjunction, all the methods I suggested would inoculate a system against the corrosive influence of wealth. Not to such a point of immunity that it could stand on its own without the intervention of a well-educated, well-meaning society, but to such a point of resistance that it would have considerable inertia against power.
I don't say with full faith that this time will be different. But I think it's worth it to keep trying. You disagree, and that's okay. Again, we share a common goal. It's okay if my reasoning doesn't seem like the most wise option to you. That's why democracy is important: the reasoning of each individual contributes toward the decision of the whole.
None of your propositions addresses the fundamental fact that capitalists presently dominate the economy and state, and you leave them open to political organizing against socialism. This is effectively saying we shouldn't stop Nazis from organizing out of a moralist belief that Nazism should be respected rather than prevented.
The reason I am trying to get you to think critically and scientifically is because we both generally think socialism is necessary. The importance of ideological struggle against reformism is so that we don't end up with an American Pinochet when reformism inevitably fails, and can instead avoid that problem entirely.
It's not out of a belief that their ideology should be respected. It shouldn't, and the government should discourage it and act against it.
But they should be allowed to gather because they, as all people, have the right to organize, so long as they do so peacefully and their speech does not consist of threats, slander, or direct calls to violence.
If you disagree with me on that, I absolutely respect your stance. Free speech is a difficult issue.
The solution to that, in my view, is participation in democracy. When millions protest, when hundreds of millions vote, we are a force against power that can force the current power—wealth—off its throne. There is a line at which it is no longer feasible to work within the system. I believe our primary disagreement is on where that line falls, and it's okay for us to disagree.
I have thought critically. We have come to different conclusions, but you cannot derive from our difference of opinion that I didn't consider the matter.
Why? This sounds like it's based in moralism, not a scientific analysis for the benefit of the working class.
Why do you believe the capitalist state can be turned against capitalism? Again, why?
I have asked for elaboration, but you haven't given any. All I can do is fill in the blanks you left for me and guess at how you came to your conclusions.
The benefit of the working class is also based in morality. Decisions for the benefit of people should always be based in morality. Ethics are well defined by holistic good, which is benefit to all.
I have elaborated on how I think power is best seized via government participation, and on how I think a ruling class can be prevented via reform once that power is seized. Part of my reasoning, as it is with all things, is rooted in the moral belief that democracy is good, and should be the foundation of governmental change.
Your stance here seems to be that reform hasn't successfully overhauled government yet, so it cannot ever. My stance is that reform hasn't worked reliably, but should not be abandoned because some changes have been made via reform as evidence of its potential, and because it is more moral to base change in democracy. You think we should cut down the tree and grow a new one. I think it's not too late to cut off branches instead. Both are reasonable stances.
We have the same context before us that leads us to our respective beliefs that reform either is or isn't worth it.
Your reasoning and moral footwork leads you to a different place than mine, and that's okay. But it seems my reasoning isn't satisfactory to you because it differs from yours.
I think it would be best if we discontinue this discussion. We've shared and clarified our respective opinions, and the border to further understanding here appears to be disagreement.
Moralism is not a scientific worldview. That does not mean we should not strive to be ethical, but, rather, that justifying Nazis and capitalists being able to organize against the working class "because its the right thing to do" is not a reason worth considering. We are workers, we should liberate the world, not wax poetic about being kind to Nazis.
You have not at all elaborated on how reform will work, you've restated your premise. You then again retreat to moralism as a reason, not science, and will walk the working class into a shallow grave, rather than liberation.
My stance is simple: the working class should prevail. We should not leave blatant holes for Nazis to abuse, nor should we base our understanding of the world on how we would like for it to be, but instead based on how it is. I believe we should avoid class suicide.
Logic on how society should be structured, though, can and should be based on morality.
The right thing to do is always a reason worth considering. It is the most important reason to consider, always.
Free speech is not a hole to be patched. It is a precious feature of democracy, not a bug in the democratic system. Can it be abused? Yes, of course. However, it should not be infringed upon. Criminalization of dissident speech is among the defining features of fascism, after all. If a system cannot exist cooperatively with free speech, it is not suitable.
I agree. But I am basing how I think we should act based on how I would like for the world to be. I am not basing my understanding on the world at present on how I would like for it to be.
It does, when measures like the ones I proposed are in place to prevent a wealthy upper class.
I agree with you on many of the points you have made. There are some issues on which we will disagree, such as free speech, the value of morality in decision-making, and whether reform has the potential to succeed.
Because it is clear we will not come to a consensus on these few matters, and because you consider the reasoning I have provided to be invalid according to your standards, this conversation will simply loop if we continue writing to each other.
I feel we have said all each of us have to say on the matter, so I will mark any replies to this thread from you as read without reply going forward. Thank you for your time and for discussing this with me. I appreciate your input, and I wish you well. God bless you.
There is absolutely no reason why we should allow Nazis to organize against socialism. None at all. Morals are not absolutes, what I consider to be morally most important is protecting the working class and moving beyond this wretched system. People should not be allowed to freely advocate for systems that result in constant eradication of the impoverished.
The reason your ideas are dangerous, and morally wrong, is because they will result in the exact same situation that has always happened: open gangsterism and massacres of the left when capital takes off its mask.