Look at this shit (first paragraph of body of article):
"Automatic watches are admired for their intricate mechanics and timeless appeal, but even the finest timepieces can sometimes run fast or slow. If you’ve noticed your automatic watch gaining or losing time, you’re not."
First search result on DDG. Thank you, automatic watch expert and real person Hnin Oo Thazin. We may need a whole ass new internet.
https://mtscwatch.com/blog/why-your-automatic-watch-runs-fast-or-slow-and-how-to-fix-it
Is the fediverse good? Can you find information that was posted here by searching in DDG/Google/...?
I think that what is lost about reddit from reddit specifically being such a shitty company that has so desperately enshittified itself to the point of comic absurdity in what feels like a blink of an eye is that... reddit is the start of a great concept. Of course any system can be gamed, we all could just be dogs on the internet pretending to be humans, but most of the time the upvoting and downvoting along with the multilayered threaded conversations allows for conversation, links and facts to surface that I find harder to find in other places and in general surprisingly sophisticated compared to other places on the internet, so yes!
Of course there is only so much here, which is where you come in!
Back in the day people posted sales notices, meeting information, etc. on cork boards or bulletin boards in high traffic areas in public places. The practice dates back to ancient Greece at a minimum. The availability of cheap paper was one of the first revolutions in the technology. When people were first able to use modems to connect personal computers to each-other, it's no surprise that one of the first things created was a digital Bulletin Board System (BBS).
Reddit isn't all that much different from a BBS. Along the way usenet news groups added some features, like organizing discussions into niche topic groups. Someone came up with the idea of adding upvotes and downvotes which (at least partially) makes good comments more visible and bad comments less visible. That's been around since at least the Slashdot era. But, Reddit and Lemmy would be pretty familiar to someone using a BBS in the early 1990s. And the basic concept would be familiar to Aristotle.
There's a reason the concept has been around so long. It's a good one. Making the forums searchable will means years or even decades worth of useful information becomes available long after the conversation ended. The problem is that when the focus becomes "how do we make money from this". That hurts multiple ways. First of all, it leads to spam comments, paid posts, and other inauthentic content. Someone sees the forum as a way to get their stuff in front of a lot of eyeballs, and that makes the site worse for everyone. Second of all, forum owners start thinking "all these eyeballs on my site, I should get paid for it" and either sells out to the first group, or restricts visibility of the information so that you have to go through them to see it (see Reddit's deals with Google and OpenAI).
IMO, the system works best when there's no one owner and most people running and moderating things are volunteers. That describes the early days of Usenet where volunteers were running Usenet nodes, often on computers owned by their schools. It also somewhat describes Reddit in the early era, when a corporation owned the site but it was basically run by volunteer mods. It also describes Lemmy and Mastodon now. The problem is that the more prominent something gets in the search results on a search engine, the bigger a target it is for scammers, spammers, propagandists, etc.
I like where the fediverse is now. It could be a bit more popular, but it's a risk that the more popular it gets, the worse it gets in other ways.
I agree with most of what you are saying but I don't think everyone has to be volunteers on the fediverse. Moderating and IT work are forms of labor, there is no reason people can't be materially supported for doing that labor, the problem comes in when the structures and systems become profit driven for social media/BBS systems. One is not the other, we can and absolutely should prioritize materially supporting the people who make the fediverse run and we need to consciously divorce that concept from monetizing fediverse social networks themselves or else we will keep burning out and taking advantage of volunteer devs, admins and moderators.
Honestly, the fact it doesn't show up on search engines much likely contributes to it staying healthy. If it becomes valuable to post here for SEO then we'll see an increase in bots using it for promotion or whatever else.
If the content and information posted here can not be found, then it is essentially useless except for that moment in time for those few that happen to read it here.
Why would you rate service quality by SEO performance? There's almost nothing you can do to make high quality information avilable to search engines while being drowned out by an infinite flood of garbage.
Information needs to be able to be found...?
Yes, actually. I know Kagi in particular has a fediverse "lens" that filters results to things found here. Unsure if anyone else has implemented that yet, or how deeply it scrapes fedi for results, but it's there.
Regardless everything that is posted here is publicly visible so any search engine that wanted to could scrape results from here.