me_irl

History has a lot of failed socialist experiments

Every socialist experiment is the end result of a failed capitalist experiment. Often, a slew of failed capitalist experiments.

But that hardly matters in the here-and-now. We're trapped in a brutal dictatorial police state governed by heartless sociopaths and their legions of dimwitted thugs. Trying to argue with ICE Agent Jonathan Ross over the finer points of economic policy won't benefit you, because he's paid very well to not listen and just keep firing.

Similarly, the pent up public desire for liberation, for democracy, and for a bit of social justice isn't going to go away because you cooked up a spreadsheet showing the long term GDP of respective socialist and capitalist states. We're well past the point of high minded academic bullshit.

all of its successes were hybrids with capitalism

Every successful socialist state has ended up having to do business with the prevailing global hegemony. Of course, you could say the same of the feudalists. Nobody got to ignore the knock-knock-knock of Theodore Roosevelt's White Fleet a century ago and Trump's US Navy hasn't been any kinder in the modern day.

But in another hundred years? If China or India or Brazil become the prevailing global economic powerhouse, I have to wonder what hegemonic propaganda your great-grandkids are going to be regurgitating to justify their own status quo.